Skip to content 
Cashmere quality differences can be summarized in one sentence: premium cashmere is made from longer, finer fibers that produce a softer, more durable, and luxurious fabric, while cheap cashmere typically comes from shorter fibers that are prone to pilling1 and have a rougher feel.
When evaluating cashmere supplied for private label2 or bespoke garment production, it is important to recognize that the disparity between cheap and pricey cashmere is not merely a matter of price but one of fundamental quality, production processes, and long-term durability. Premium-grade cashmere originates from specific breeds of goats known for their long and fine fibers, ensuring superior softness and reduced pilling. In contrast, cheaper cashmere products often use fibers from hybridized or lower-quality goats that produce shorter fibers, leading to a fabric that may wear out more quickly.
The key differentiation lies in the fiber itself:
-
Length and Fineness: Pricey cashmere fibers are longer and finer, often classified as Grade A3. This results in a smoother fabric that drapes well and provides enhanced comfort. The fiber diameter is also crucial; premium cashmere typically has diameters less than 19 microns, ensuring a superior tactile experience.
-
Short vs. Long Fibers: Cheap cashmere generally involves short fibers that may be sourced during a period of mass production and intensive breeding. These short fibers not only result in a coarser texture but also have a higher tendency to pill when subjected to friction, which affects the garment’s longevity and appearance.
-
Source and Consistency: Authentic high-quality cashmere usually comes from carefully bred goats in specific regions where the climate and care conditions are optimal for producing luxurious fiber. In contrast, low-cost alternatives might result from less controlled breeding environments, leading to inconsistent quality.
For high-end cashmere production, sourcing starts at the farm. Farms with stringent quality controls collect cashmere during the molting season by combing the naturally shed soft undercoat. This process guarantees that only the finest fibers are gathered, resulting in a fabric that demonstrates both softness and durability.
On the other hand, cheaper cashmere may be collected mechanically, mixing fibers from different grades, which diminishes the overall quality. This blend of fibers can lead to fabric inconsistencies, affecting both the production process and the final product's performance.
After collection, cashmere undergoes several processes including dehairing, spinning, and weaving. In premium operations:
- Dehairing4 is highly selective, ensuring that only the soft undercoat fibers are kept.
- Spinning techniques are refined to maintain the integrity of long, fine fibers.
- Weaving and finishing processes are carefully controlled to produce a garment that is exceptionally soft, durable, and resistant to pilling.
Cheaper cashmere productions might cut corners during these stages. They often employ less selective dehairing and more automated methods that can damage fibers or mix high-quality and lower-quality strands together. The result is a fabric that, from a tactile perspective, does not match the standards of its premium counterpart.
Apart from raw material sourcing and processing, the final finish applied to the cashmere fabric is another major quality marker:
-
Premium cashmere garments often receive additional finishing treatments that enhance softness and resistance to wear. These treatments help the fabric maintain its appearance over prolonged use.
-
Cost-effective cashmere products might lack these additional processes, making them vulnerable to early pilling and wear, which diminishes the perceived value over time.
A thorough quality check is also essential:
-
Pilling resistance tests: Premium cashmere undergoes rigorous evaluation, ensuring that even after multiple washes, the fabric retains its luxurious feel and does not form unsightly pills.
-
Softness and hand-feel evaluation: Authentic high-quality cashmere should feel smooth against the skin, without any roughness or irritation—a critical factor in consumer satisfaction for high-end brands.
To assist sourcing managers and brand owners in making an informed decision, the following table breaks down the key differences between cheap and pricey cashmere:
| Feature | Premium Cashmere | Cheap Cashmere |
|---|---|---|
| Fiber Length | Long, continuous fibers | Short fibers |
| Fiber Fineness | Less than 19 microns (Grade A) | 19+ microns; typically Grade B or C |
| Sourcing | Selectively sourced from specialized breeds | Mechanically or haphazardly sourced |
| Production Process | Extensive manual and controlled processing | Automated, less selective processing |
| Softness & Hand Feel | Exceptionally soft and smooth | Can feel rough or slightly itchy |
| Durability / Pilling | High resistance to pilling | Prone to pilling and quicker wear |
| Cost-Effectiveness (Long-Term) | High initial cost but offers better longevity | Lower upfront cost with shorter lifespan |
This table clearly illustrates that while cheaper cashmere might be attractive from an initial cost perspective, it often compromises on critical quality aspects that influence consumer satisfaction and durability.
For brands, especially in the luxury or mid-to-high-end market segments, using premium cashmere can significantly enhance brand perception. The tactile quality, longevity, and overall appearance of a garment made from high-quality cashmere can justify a higher retail price and attract discerning customers. Investing in premium raw materials also aligns with a brand’s commitment to quality and sustainability—an appealing proposition in today's fashion industry.
In situations where budget constraints are a primary concern, the trade-off is between accepting a lower quality material that might fast-track product turnover or opting for a higher initial investment that results in superior performance. It is important for procurement managers not only to evaluate cost metrics in isolation but also to factor in long-term costs:
- Frequent returns or complaints may arise with garments that quickly degrade.
- Additional production costs related to reworking or customer dissatisfaction can offset initial savings with cheap cashmere.
- Brand reputation: Consistently delivering a premium product increases customer loyalty and brand value which is hard to quantify in simple production costs.
Consider a high-end fashion brand that uses Grade A3 cashmere for its product line. Though the upfront cost is higher, the garments have a longer lifecycle and maintain their luxurious appeal, supporting premium pricing in the market. Conversely, a brand that opts for cheaper cashmere might lower production costs but risks higher rates of product returns and negative customer feedback due to early signs of wear and pilling. Such data-backed decisions are crucial for an informed sourcing strategy.
For sourcing managers looking to make a more technical evaluation of cashmere, here are some practical metrics:
-
Fiber Diameter (Microns): Always aim for fibers less than 19 microns for premium quality. A lower micron count is directly associated with softer, finer cashmere.
-
Fiber Length Measurement: Longer fibers usually indicate a higher quality grade. In premium grades, fibers are measured to be significantly longer than those used in cheaper variants.
-
Pilling Resistance Tests: Standard tests, such as the Martindale Abrasion test5, can simulate wear over time. Premium cashmere typically shows minimal pilling results in these controlled environments.
-
Visual and Tactile Inspection: This involves a side-by-side comparison where sourcing managers can feel the difference. High-quality cashmere should be smooth, with a natural sheen and minimal rough areas.
A standardized testing protocol can be implemented to ensure consistency across different production batches. The following simple workflow can serve as an internal guideline:
| Testing Phase | Description | Expected Outcome |
|---|---|---|
| Visual Inspection | Check for even color, consistent texture, and sheen | Uniform appearance, smoothness |
| Fiber Micron Measurement | Measure fiber thickness using precision tools | Below 19 microns |
| Abrasion Test | Apply controlled abrasion to a fabric sample | Minimal pilling observed |
| Hand Feel Assessment | Evaluate softness through tactile testing | Smooth, luxurious, non-itchy |
- Develop Strong Supplier Relationships: Work closely with suppliers to understand their sourcing and processing methods. Request fiber testing data and sample garments to physically assess quality before large orders.
- Customized Quality Checks: Build in customized checkpoints during production to affirm each batch’s quality. Use the standardized testing protocol mentioned above.
- Cost-Benefit Analysis: Weigh the long-term benefits of premium cashmere—especially for brands targeting a luxury market—against the allure of immediate cost savings with cheaper alternatives.
- Prioritize Customer Experience: From the initial design to the final product finish, emphasize the end-user experience. Ensure that high-quality cashmere is showcased in the design, capitalizing on its superior feel and durability.
- Innovation in Finishing: Consider investing in advanced finishing techniques that can further enhance the softness and durability of cashmere. This might include eco-friendly treatments that add both value and market appeal.
- Prototype Testing: Always develop prototypes with multiple quality grades. Test consumer reactions and longevity of the product before finalizing the production plan.
Understanding the true differences between cheap and pricey cashmere allows both sourcing managers and brand owners to make decisions that are not just cost-effective in the short term but also build the foundation for long-term brand success. Investing in quality may lead to higher initial costs, but the benefits of customer satisfaction, reduced product returns, and enhanced brand reputation often outweigh these expenses over time.
Good cashmere is produced from longer, fine fibers sourced from carefully managed herds, resulting in a fabric that is soft, durable, and resistant to pilling. Cheap cashmere largely derives from shorter fibers that are more prone to pilling and wear, leading to a rougher feel and inconsistent quality.
High-quality cashmere will feel extremely soft and smooth against the skin, without causing itchiness, due to its longer and finer fibers. In contrast, low-quality cashmere may feel scratchy, indicating the presence of shorter or mixed fibers that compromise the overall fabric quality.
Yes, cashmere is typically classified into grades. Grade A represents the finest, softest cashmere with the longest fibers (usually less than 19 microns), while Grade B and C are progressively coarser with slightly thicker fibers, impacting both softness and durability.
-
pilling: Read more about pilling, a common textile issue where short fibers form small balls on the fabric surface, affecting the material’s appearance and durability. ↩
-
private label: Click to learn about the concept of private label products and how they enable brands to market customized products without owning the manufacturing process. ↩
-
Grade A: Discover the significance of Grade A cashmere in quality assurance, detailing the strict standards that define premium fiber characteristics. ↩ ↩2
-
Dehairing: Learn about the dehairing process, a critical step in cashmere production where only the finest undercoat fibers are retained to ensure superior softness. ↩
-
Martindale Abrasion test: Explore the Martindale Abrasion test, a standardized method for evaluating fabric durability and resistance to wear through simulated friction. ↩
